Mandela-RF cross-comparison: Ontario provincial vs federal SIU — morie_otis_analyze_otis_mandela_provincial_vs

Cross-references the c11 Mandela classification against the Sprott-Doob Feb 2021 federal SIU figures (Table 19, N=1960).

Usage

morie_otis_analyze_otis_mandela_provincial_vs_federal(data, out_dir = NULL)

Arguments

data: c11 data.frame (used to derive the provincial figures).
out_dir: Optional output directory.

Value

morie_otis_analysis_result.

Examples

# \donttest{
otis_c11 <- morie_synth_otis("c11", n = 120L, seed = 1L)
morie_otis_analyze_otis_mandela_provincial_vs_federal(otis_c11)
#> Mandela-RF cross-comparison -- Ontario provincial (OTIS) vs federal SIUs (Sprott-Doob T19)
#> ==========================================================================================
#>   Federal SIU reference                       Solitary 28.4%, Torture 9.9% (N=1960)
#>   Provincial peak torture-rate (Segregation)  53.6% in 2019
#>   Provincial-vs-federal gap (peak)            +43.7 percentage points (higher provincially)
#>   Caveat                                      Federal: person-stays + full Mandela operationalization; Provincial: individuals + duration only.
#> 
#> Federal vs Provincial Mandela classification:
#>   Source                               Period                Unit          Solitary %  Torture %  N
#>   ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#>   Federal SIUs (CSC, Sprott-Doob T19)  Nov 2019 - Sept 2020  Person-stays  28.4%       9.9%       1960
#>   Ontario Provincial Segregation       2018                  Individuals   69.3%       30.7%      641
#>   Ontario Provincial Segregation       2019                  Individuals   46.4%       53.6%      666
#>   Ontario Provincial Segregation       2020                  Individuals   74.1%       25.9%      522
#>   Ontario Provincial Segregation       2021                  Individuals   55.2%       44.8%      543
#>   Ontario Provincial Segregation       2022                  Individuals   81.8%       18.2%      566
#>   Ontario Provincial Segregation       2023                  Individuals   50.7%       49.3%      765
#>   Ontario Provincial Segregation       2024                  Individuals   66.1%       33.9%      744
#>   Ontario Provincial RC (broader)      2018                  Individuals   70.9%       29.1%      841
#>   Ontario Provincial RC (broader)      2019                  Individuals   46.0%       54.0%      807
#>   Ontario Provincial RC (broader)      2020                  Individuals   67.5%       32.5%      406
#>   Ontario Provincial RC (broader)      2021                  Individuals   72.2%       27.8%      558
#>   Ontario Provincial RC (broader)      2022                  Individuals   71.9%       28.1%      659
#>   Ontario Provincial RC (broader)      2023                  Individuals   48.1%       51.9%      877
#>   Ontario Provincial RC (broader)      2024                  Individuals   78.7%       21.3%      953
#> 
#> Cross-comparison of Mandela-Rules classifications -- federal SIUs (9.9% torture headline) vs Ontario provincial (OTIS c11). Note unit + operationalization differences; the comparison is directionally informative but not perfectly apples-to-apples. 
# }