Hill (1975): the mean log-excess of the top k order statistics over the (k+1)-st. Consistent ONLY for xi > 0 (Frechet-type, regularly varying tails); non-positive data at the threshold are an error, not a silent log of a negative number. The choice of k is THE problem – variance falls and bias grows with k – so when k is omitted the whole Hill plot is returned alongside the default, because a single number hides exactly the instability a user needs to see. The asymptotic SE xi/sqrt(k) is honest only in the bias-free regime and says so.
